Trade dress refers to the visual appearance of a product or its packaging that signifies the source of the product to consumers. It includes elements such as size, shape, color, texture, and design. For example, the distinctive shape of a Coca-Cola bottle or the decor of an Apple store are considered trade dress. Trade dress and trademarks are closely related concepts within intellectual property law, both serving to identify and distinguish the source of goods or services in the marketplace. While trademarks are often easier to register, trade dress can also be registered if it meets the criteria of distinctiveness and non-functionality.
In the OMG Girlz case, the group claimed that the dolls’ appearance closely mimicked their own distinctive style, which constituted trade dress infringement. By copying their unique look, MGA Entertainment was accused of creating confusion among consumers and diluting the OMG Girlz’s brand identity.
Unfair competition encompasses various deceptive or wrongful business practices that cause economic harm to other businesses. It can be broadly divided into two categories: deceptive trade practices and unfair trade practices. Deceptive trade practices often involve actions that confuse consumers about the source of a product, such as trademark infringement and trade dress violation. Unfair trade practices include a wider range of wrongful actions, such as false advertising, bait-and-switch tactics, unauthorized substitution of one brand for another, use of confidential information by former employees, theft of trade secrets, breach of restrictive covenants, trade libel, and false representation of products or services.
In this lawsuit, the OMG Girlz alleged that MGA Entertainment engaged in unfair competition by using their likenesses and trade dress to gain an unfair advantage in the market. This practice not only harmed the OMG Girlz’s brand but also violated principles of fair play in commerce.
The legal battle between the OMG Girlz and MGA Entertainment was protracted, involving multiple trials and legal maneuvers. Initially, MGA sought a declaratory judgment to assert that they had not infringed on any intellectual property rights. However, the OMG Girlz counterclaimed, leading to a series of trials. In the most recent trial, a federal jury awarded the OMG Girlz $71 million in damages, including both real and punitive damages. The jury found that MGA Entertainment had indeed misappropriated the OMG Girlz’s likenesses and infringed on their trade dress. This verdict underscores the importance of respecting intellectual property rights and the potential consequences of failing to do so.
This case serves as a cautionary tale for companies and individuals in the entertainment industry. It highlights the need for clear permissions and agreements when using another person’s likeness or distinctive style. Moreover, it underscores the legal protections available to individuals and groups whose identities and creative expressions are misappropriated. As the OMG Girlz case demonstrates, the legal system can provide recourse for those whose intellectual property rights are violated. It also serves as a reminder of the ongoing need to balance creative freedom with respect for the rights of others.
If you or your business need assistance with intellectual property matters, our experienced legal team is here to help. Request a call today.
