As AI continues to revolutionize various industries, understanding the nuances of copyright law is crucial for protecting intellectual property and leveraging AI effectively. In general, work that a human does not create is not protected by copyright law. This issue has been increasingly challenged with the increased use of artificial intelligence. The U.S. Copyright Office’s recent report on the copyrightability of AI-generated content clarifies what can and cannot be protected. These findings have significant implications for business owners. Below, we will discuss the three instances in which AI-created work may be protected by copyright law.
- Enhanced Protection for Human Creativity
The report emphasizes that copyright protection is available when sufficient human involvement is involved in the creation process. AI can be a powerful tool to assist human creativity, but it cannot replace it. AI can be used to enhance human expression in various ways, such as brainstorming ideas, refining plots, or assisting with editing. For example, a marketing team might use AI to generate ideas for a campaign, but the final creative decisions and execution must come from human team members. This ensures that the resulting work is eligible for copyright protection.
Here are some key points:
Original Human Work: The original work created by a human must be copyrightable on its own. This means that the human-authored input must meet the originality standard required for copyright protection. For example, if a writer creates a story and uses AI to generate illustrations based on that story, the original text is protected by copyright; however, the AI-generated illustrations may not be.
Perceptible Human Contribution: The human-authored elements must be clearly perceptible in the final AI-generated output. This means that the AI-generated content should reflect the human author’s creative choices and contributions. For instance, if an artist creates a sketch and uses AI to add colors and details, the final image should still show the original sketch as a significant part of the work.
Assistive Role of AI: AI can assist in enhancing human expression but cannot replace it. The report emphasizes that AI should be used as a tool to assist human creativity rather than making expressive choices independently. This ensures that the final work reflects human authorship and is eligible for copyright protection.
- Opportunities for Creative Compilation
The U.S. Copyright Office’s report on AI-generated content provides valuable insights into how the selection, coordination, and arrangement of AI-generated material can be eligible for copyright protection. Selection, coordination, and arrangement refer to the creative process of choosing, organizing, and combining various elements to create a cohesive and original work. This principle is often applied to compilations, where the individual components may not be copyrightable on their own, but the way they are combined reflects human creativity and originality. Here are some key points:
Creative Choices: The human author must make creative choices in selecting which AI-generated elements to use, how to organize them, and how to present them. For example, a graphic designer might use AI to generate multiple images and then creatively arrange them into a unique collage. The originality in the arrangement is what makes the work eligible for copyright protection.
Compilation of Elements: The overall compilation of AI-generated elements must reflect the author’s creative input. This means that simply using AI to generate content is not enough; the human must actively engage in the creative process. For instance, a publisher might use AI to generate text snippets and then compile them into a book with a specific structure and flow. The creative compilation of these snippets is protected.
- Value Addition Through Modifications
The report highlights that significant modifications or enhancements to AI-generated content can be registered for copyright protection. This is particularly beneficial for businesses in industries like publishing, media, and entertainment, where content is frequently edited and refined. By ensuring these modifications are protected, businesses can maintain control over their unique contributions and prevent unauthorized use.
Here are some key points:
Creative Input: The human author must make substantial creative contributions to the AI-generated material. This could involve editing, refining, or adding new elements that demonstrate originality. For example, if an AI generates a basic image, and a human artist adds intricate details, colors, and textures, these modifications reflect human creativity and can be protected by copyright.
Degree of Modification: The extent of the modifications must be significant enough to meet the originality standard. Minor tweaks or adjustments may not be sufficient. The modifications should transform the AI-generated content into a new work that showcases the human author’s creative choices. For instance, rewriting AI-generated text to include unique perspectives, anecdotes, or stylistic elements can make the final work eligible for copyright protection.
Creative Control and Expression
The report also points out that prompts alone do not provide sufficient control over the output to make the user the author of the generated content. Even highly detailed prompts can produce different outputs each time they are used, highlighting the unpredictability of AI systems. For a work to be copyrightable, the human must have control over the creative expression. This means that business owners should focus on how they can use AI to assist their creative processes while maintaining control over the final output.
The determination of whether a work is copyrightable is made on a case-by-case basis. This means that each work must be evaluated individually to assess the extent of human involvement. For business owners, this means that documenting the creative process and the human contribution to the final product is crucial. Keeping detailed records can help establish authorship and protect intellectual property.
For more on copyrights and AI, register for our workshop Copyrights, AI, and Your Business.
Register Here
